Bartko Pavia LLP
  • About
    • Locations
  • Services
    • Practices
    • Industries
  • Professionals
  • Insights & News
    • Events
    • Honors & Awards
    • Media Mentions
    • Press Releases
    • Publications
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Careers

Bartko Pavia Files Motion for Sanctions Against Walmart on Behalf of Zest Labs Over Alleged Concealed Patents

  1. | Home
  2. | Insights & News
  3. | Media Mentions
  • Print
  • PDF
    Share this page

Media Mentions

25, October 2024

San Francisco, CA – October 25, 2024 – As featured in Law 360– Patrick Ryan, co-managing partner of Bartko LLP, and a specialist in intellectual property and trade secret litigation, has filed a motion for sanctions against Walmart Inc. on behalf of Zest Labs, Inc. The motion, filed with the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas, accuses Walmart of withholding critical patent-related evidence in ongoing litigation over Zest’s proprietary shelf-freshness technology.

Patrick, who brings decades of experience in high-stakes corporate litigation, is part of the team representing Zest Labs in this complex dispute. “Walmart not only exploited Zest’s trade secrets under the guise of a partnership but also secretly filed patent applications for the very technology at the center of this case,” said Patrick. “Such actions undermine the integrity of the legal process and threaten the protection of proprietary information.”

The motion filed by Patrick and his colleagues seeks additional discovery, jury instructions addressing Walmart’s alleged misconduct, and financial sanctions. Zest Labs had initially been awarded $115 million in damages, but a retrial was ordered following the discovery of concealed patent applications that could have influenced the original verdict.

Patrick’s representation of Zest Labs is supported by his skilled team at Bartko LLP, including attorneys Sean R. McTigue, Kenneth L. Richard, Natalie A. Felsen, Scott P. Richardson, H. Christopher Bartolomucci, and Kate M. Falkenstien. This case demonstrates Bartko’s track record of results advocating and protecting the IP rights of our clients.

To view the full Law360 article click here.

Contact: Patrick M. Ryan | pryan@bartkolaw.com | 415.291.4540

Related Services

  • Intellectual Property
  • Technology

Related Professionals

Patrick M. Ryan

Patrick M. Ryan

Co-Managing Partner

Email

415.956.1900

Sean R. McTigue

Sean R. McTigue

Partner

Email

415.956.1900

Kenneth Richard

Kenneth Richard

Special Counsel

Email

415.956.1900

Insights & News

Press Release

30, October 2025

An Ruda Serves as Judge at the Berkeley Female Founders & Funders Summit

Learn more

Honors and Awards

17, May 2023

Patrick M. Ryan Ranked Top IP Lawyer

Learn more

Media Mentions

27, October 2025

Steve Vieux Featured in Law360 Coverage of the California Lawyers Association’s Golden State Institute

Learn more

Press Release

17, December 2025

Bartko Pavia Elevates Four Attorneys to Partnership

Learn more

Honors and Awards

26, November 2025

Patrick M. Ryan Named to Daily Journal’s 2025 “Top Antitrust Lawyers” List

Learn more

Honors and Awards

23, September 2025

Patrick M. Ryan Earns Repeat Recognition as 2025 Top 100 Lawyer

Learn more

Media Mentions

30, May 2025

Zest Labs $222M Verdict Gains Widespread Media Coverage

Learn more

Honors and Awards

01, January 2025

Bartko Pavia Earns Recognition in 2025 Best Law Firms® Rankings

Learn more

Press Release

31, May 2019

Bartko Pavia Firm Obtains $845,114,000 Judgment for ASML Against XTAL, Inc.

Learn more

Press Release

01, August 2025

Bartko Pavia Continues Strategic Expansion with Addition of Antitrust Partner Ian Papendick

Learn more

Media Mentions

05, February 2024

Bartko Pavia Obtains Defense Win in Uber Trade Secret Case

Learn more

Honors and Awards

24, January 2024

Patrick M. Ryan Named Leading Commercial Litigator

Learn more

Press Release

14, May 2025

Bartko Pavia’s Patrick M. Ryan obtains $222 million jury verdict against Walmart

Learn more

Honors and Awards

08, November 2023

Bartko Pavia Ranked Top Litigation Boutique

Learn more

Press Release

11, March 2022

Bartko Pavia Scores Huge Defense Jury Verdict in $411 Million Sutter Health Antitrust Class Action

Learn more

Press Release

07, February 2023

Bartko Pavia Clients Win $680 Million Francesca Naify Case

Learn more

Press Release

30, October 2025

An Ruda Serves as Judge at the Berkeley Female Founders & Funders Summit

Learn more

Honors and Awards

17, May 2023

Patrick M. Ryan Ranked Top IP Lawyer

Learn more

Media Mentions

27, October 2025

Steve Vieux Featured in Law360 Coverage of the California Lawyers Association’s Golden State Institute

Learn more

Press Release

17, December 2025

Bartko Pavia Elevates Four Attorneys to Partnership

Learn more

Honors and Awards

26, November 2025

Patrick M. Ryan Named to Daily Journal’s 2025 “Top Antitrust Lawyers” List

Learn more

Honors and Awards

23, September 2025

Patrick M. Ryan Earns Repeat Recognition as 2025 Top 100 Lawyer

Learn more

Media Mentions

30, May 2025

Zest Labs $222M Verdict Gains Widespread Media Coverage

Learn more

Honors and Awards

01, January 2025

Bartko Pavia Earns Recognition in 2025 Best Law Firms® Rankings

Learn more

Press Release

31, May 2019

Bartko Pavia Firm Obtains $845,114,000 Judgment for ASML Against XTAL, Inc.

Learn more

Press Release

01, August 2025

Bartko Pavia Continues Strategic Expansion with Addition of Antitrust Partner Ian Papendick

Learn more

Media Mentions

05, February 2024

Bartko Pavia Obtains Defense Win in Uber Trade Secret Case

Learn more

Honors and Awards

24, January 2024

Patrick M. Ryan Named Leading Commercial Litigator

Learn more

Press Release

14, May 2025

Bartko Pavia’s Patrick M. Ryan obtains $222 million jury verdict against Walmart

Learn more

Honors and Awards

08, November 2023

Bartko Pavia Ranked Top Litigation Boutique

Learn more

Press Release

11, March 2022

Bartko Pavia Scores Huge Defense Jury Verdict in $411 Million Sutter Health Antitrust Class Action

Learn more

Press Release

07, February 2023

Bartko Pavia Clients Win $680 Million Francesca Naify Case

Learn more

Press Release

30, October 2025

An Ruda Serves as Judge at the Berkeley Female Founders & Funders Summit

Learn more

Honors and Awards

17, May 2023

Patrick M. Ryan Ranked Top IP Lawyer

Learn more

Media Mentions

27, October 2025

Steve Vieux Featured in Law360 Coverage of the California Lawyers Association’s Golden State Institute

Learn more

View all Insights

Bartko Pavia LLP
  • About
  • Services
  • Professionals
  • Insights & News
  • Careers

© 2025 Bartko Pavia LLP | All Rights Reserved

  • Make Payment: LawPay
  • Disclaimers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Cookie Settings